How to identify Tenerife restaurants which suit you

I have a love hate relationship with Tripadvisor. On the one hand it’s a good source of useful information about destinations like Tenerife, on the other it’s also full of misinformation and opinions which are seriously subjective. None more so than when it comes to restaurant reviews.

We all have differing tastes when it comes to food. Some folk like to play it safe and stick to familiarity, some like trying new culinary experiences. Some like traditional, others like contemporary dining. Then there are those, like us, who enjoy trying them all. I tend to think of eating out in the same way as deciding what movie to watch. Sometimes I want to see something thought-provoking or obscure, sometimes I want pure escapism. Similarly, one day I can have a yen for a burger, or fish and chips. On another I fancy a tasting menu featuring dishes which look like they could belong in an art gallery.

Canarian Burger, Santa Cruz, Tenerife
When I fancy a burger I want it to be a good one, like this Canarian burger in Santa Cruz.

What this boils down to for anyone looking for restaurant recommendations is who can you trust? Which also really means knowing who, of the zillions of people writing restaurant reviews, likes the same food as you do?

People get caught out all of the time because they’ve gone for restaurants which lie in elevated positions on Tripadvisor’s best restaurants in a given destination. But just because a restaurant occupies the number one spot in, say, Los Cristianos it doesn’t mean it’s going to wow your tastebuds.

Kazan, Santa Cruz, Tenerife
Michelin star seafood at Kazan in Santa Cruz.

Opinions about the good, the bad, and the ugly of Tenerife restaurants are often down to the wildly varying experiences of the people who review restaurants. That old saying ‘one person’s meat is another person’s poison’ (that’s the modern version) is perfect for being applied to restaurant reviews. I often read reviews where the author has been disappointed having tried a restaurant which was highly rated on Tripadvisor. Some behave as though they’ve been lied to. They haven’t; they’ve just chosen badly. It might be that the food is simply not to their taste yet is as good as others say. But, equally well, it might be the food isn’t as good as the majority claim and a restaurant has been artificially elevated into a higher position than it might be if it was located somewhere else in the island. In a sea of mediocre restaurants anywhere half decent stands out.

Bangers and Mash, Empire, Las Americas, Tenerife
Unlike some places, Empire in Playa de las Americas are happy to advertise their food as high end pub grub, and it’s good.

These musings were prompted by a discussion on Tenerife about a popular restaurant in Los Cristianos where some people raved about it being a 5 star dining experience whilst a minority classed it as being little more than upmarket pub grub. We haven’t eaten at this particular Tenerife restaurant so I did what I always do when I check out any reviews for any destination. I looked at the photographs and made up my mind on whose reviews sounded most trustworthy based on the visual evidence. I don’t discount the minority when it comes to reviews as there have been plenty of times those are the ones I’ve agreed with.

Cherne albondigas, Tito's Bodeguita, Puerto de la Cruz, Tenerife
Cherne albondigas, contemporary Canarian cuisine at Tito’s Bodeguita near Puerto de la Cruz.

Photos speak volumes. They show us what a restaurant and the food it serves actually looks like. When people speak of upmarket restaurants I have a certain expectation of the decor, just as I would if it was a traditional Canarian restaurant, or a tapas bar. Photos show whether the restaurant matches reviewers’ descriptions. And they also reveal a lot more. If a review talks about a restaurant being ‘off the beaten track’ whilst photos show it as being in a commercial centre in Costa Adeje, then that’s another I can take with a pinch of salt.

Calamari, Italian tapas, Tenerife
This was a tapa of fried squid, but in an Italian tapas restaurant.

In one discussion about good tapas bars there was one place which a few folk raved about. A quick look at the photos showed a local (a lot in a commercial centre) whose frontage advertised it as specialising in Italian food. The Italians do have their own version of tapas, but I’m guessing Italian tapas wasn’t what the person who asked about tapas on a Spanish island was seeking.

In another example when a query was posted about where to eat fresh fish and seafood in a southern resort, photos of one of the restaurants recommended showed it to not only be inland, but also to be Italian – this is on an island which has loads of wonderful Canarian fish & seafood restaurants at the coast.

Fish platter, Cofradia de pescadores, Puerto de la Cruz, Tenerife
If you want fish & seafood on Tenerife, there are loads of Canarian restaurants to choose from.

People regularly talk of the food in a restaurant being Michelin standard yet accompanying photos invariably show dishes which are a bit of a messy mish-mash. The food might be tasty, but the presentation shows not Michelin level. There are a lot of aspirational cooks out there who think making swirly designs with various sauces and piling ingredients into towers means creative cooking. Real Michelin dishes are usually creatively neat and original in presentation. But meaningless terms are bandied around willy nilly when it comes to TA reviews. Going back to the discussion about whether the restaurant was 5 star or elevated pub grub (because they served pies and fish and chips) one person remarked that Michelin restaurants all over the world serve fish and chips. No they don’t, that’s just one of those cases of somebody just saying the first thing that comes into their heads to back up the point they’re trying to make. But if they did it would probably be served looking like a carrot (I’ve been in a Michelin kitchen where a famous chef was trying to make a pea taste like a mushroom).

Aspirational fine dining in south west Tenerife
Making patterns with sauces doesn’t make it Michelin standard cuisine.

There’s a restaurant in Puerto de la Cruz which at least one reviewer described as ‘being like a Michelin star experience’. I took my mum to eat there because she’s not particularly adventurous when it comes to food. Photos showed the dishes to be nicely presented but safe, in a familiar meat and two veg sort of way. She loved the food, but I know she wouldn’t be impressed with a real Michelin dining experience.

Smoked eel, El Rincon de Juan Carlos, Los Gigantes, Tenerife
Michelin star food is often artistically presented and, more importantly, tastes quite unique.

Even a restaurant’s name can be misleading. Just because it’s in Spanish doesn’t make it a Canarian or Spanish restaurant. In one instance the first photo of a Spanish sounding restaurant in Los Cristianos showed a menu which included the likes of prawn cocktail, beef bourguignon and battered cod and chips.

Bambi, Puerto de la Cruz, Tenerife
It’s not a Michelin star experience, but it is good food… and my mum loved it.

So whilst others resort to verbal jousting to insist their views about a restaurant are the valid ones, leapfrog over them and check out the review photos. If you like the look of the restaurant and the photos of the food get the juices flowing, the chances are it’s a restaurant which should suit you.

About Jack 434 Articles
Jack is co-editor, writer and photographer for BuzzTrips and the Real Tenerife series of travel websites as well as a contributor to online travel sites and travel magazines. Follow Jack on Facebook

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.